AI Systems · Systems and Thinking
Claims, Evidence, and Review
A claim is a statement that can be inspected. Evidence is material considered in relation to a claim. A review decision records what a named reviewer accepted, returned for changes, did not accept, or left unresolved for a stated purpose. These roles should remain separate.
Sources & review
Evidence and review
How Atlas supports this record.
Atlas uses original Kinesema wording. These public sources support narrow parts of the record; they are not endorsements or proof of claims outside the roles shown below.
- Review
- Human reviewed
- AI assistance
- Yes—human reviewed
- Last reviewed
- 2026-08-23
RDF 1.1 Concepts and Abstract Syntax
World Wide Web Consortium
- Used here for
- RDF provides one formal graph data model for representing information as subject-predicate-object triples.
- Source use
- Paraphrased from source
- Source type
- W3C Recommendation
PROV-DM: The PROV Data Model
World Wide Web Consortium
- Used here for
- Provenance can describe entities, activities, agents, and relations such as generation, usage, derivation, attribution, association, and delegation.
- Source use
- Paraphrased from source
- Source type
- W3C Recommendation
ECO: the Evidence and Conclusion Ontology, an update for 2022
Suvarna Nadendla et al.
- Used here for
- Within biomedical biocuration, ECO distinguishes evidence types from assertion methods and supports capturing evidence for assertions with provenance and quality-control roles.
- Source use
- Paraphrased from source
- Source type
- peer-reviewed primary project report
This is a concise first-release record, not a complete course. Examples, terminology, and reviewed connections can grow through later public projections.
Follow the structure
Connected concepts
These are reviewed Atlas relationships, not suggestions inferred from page order or visual proximity. Open a boundary only when you want the extra detail.
Connected from
Knowledge Graphs and Relationships
A graph may record claims and connect them with evidence or review state, but the encoded node or edge remains a statement to inspect rather than proof by itself.
Connection boundary
This relationship does not turn graph structure, connectivity, or consistency into truth, consensus, or evidential sufficiency.
Connected from
Parsers and Structured Transformation
A parser result can become material for later evaluation or review while remaining distinguishable from a reviewed claim or accepted interpretation.
Connection boundary
Passing parser rules or tests does not turn generated structure into truth, evidence sufficiency, linguistic acceptance, or approval.
Connected from
Provenance and Sources
Provenance helps distinguish a source claim, evidence considered for or against it, transformations applied to it, and the later review decision.
Connection boundary
Knowing the origin of material does not determine whether the evidence is sufficient or which conclusion a reviewer must reach.